by gastric on Thu Jul 22, 2010 7:25 pm
Just picked up an iRig and Amplitube free for my wife to use with her bass guitar as she loves her iPod Touch to death and her current Line6 software based practice setup is annoying to use as it kills the internal sound card and disconnects her computer speakers. I was going to buy a used Korg Pandora which would let her feed bass and her iPod and sum them to headphones but this seemed like an even better, not to mention cheaper, solution.
I'm home right now and she's not so I'm testing it with my bass guitar and my iPhone 3GS running OS4. She has an iPod Touch 32GB.
Note I have not yet purchased any additional paid add-ons, I'm only using Amplitube FREE.
Here are some comments based on my first 30 minutes of playing with this.
* Biggest issue - It is much too difficult to play along with MP3s. For starters, you can only play along with MP3 if you have computers and your phone all on the same WIFI network. I do, but I'd think some users wouldn't and you're eliminating their ability to play with MP3. I don't want to understand the technical issues, I just want it to be easy. You should be able to fully access the music on my device and import them within Amplitube without an external tools necessary. I'm an iDiot with an iPhone, this should be be silly, stupid easy. The lengthy "expanding" process that occurs the first time you play a song within Amplitube is annoying, but I can deal with that.
* There should be a way to purchase ALL add-ons in an inexpensive bundle. If there is, I didn't see this offered directly within the Amplitube iPhone app. I only saw each effect/amp offered individually. I haven't checked the iTunes store yet, but I'd hope there's a way to just buy EVERYTHING offered in one fell swoop.
* There should be a clean amp provided with the free version. I am initially trying this with my bass and it's fairly unusable due to the distortion applied even with low gain on the free LEAD amp. I have to have Gain set to 2 or less to kill the high frequency noise and bring the bass into a more audible spectrum. However, Gain = 2 also kills nearly all of the instrument volume, even with Volume = 10 and headphone volume all the way up. I can still hear my bass, it's just not particularly loud now.
* There is a LOT of background noise that I have not been able to get rid of. Plug no instrument into the iRig at all and you can hear a lot of "unstable" mid/low frequency noise. The Noise Filter effect does an excellent job of removing the high end hiss but not this mid/low frequency noise.
* Interacting with the app often causes the sound to break up and sometimes background noises are amplified during this time. For example, have a song playing, then click between Song and Tools. I was on FX1 playing with the free distortion, clicked Add Amp/FX, and there was ear crunching static blasted through my headphones for a second or two.
* Sometimes there's just random bouts of much louder noise. I'm sitting here, instrument with volume all the way down, iPhone just sitting on my desk with Amplitube on, and occasionally I'll get a few seconds of really loud noise in my headphones.
* If you want to hear some REALLY loud noise, click Tools and turn on the Tuner. It's almost unbearably loud and obnoxious. At this time I have no instrument cable plugged into the iRig and the amp's main volume is set to the absolute minimum. Unsure why engaging the tuner has this effect on the noise floor. Testing this further, I unplugged my iRig and plugged headphones straight into the iPhone and couldn't hear this same thing, so that leads me to believe the iRig is adding the noise I'm hearing. Playing just a song, no instrument connected to iRig, then turning on the tuner significantly boosts the song's volume. Odd stuff related to the tuner. Note the tuner itself works well.
* I'm not sure how I did this, but at some point from bopping around the app I managed to get Amplitube so it wouldn't apply any of the FX. I'd select an effects in any of the blocks, toggle the bypass, the effect would never be applied even though visually the bypass was off (effect on). I had to restart Amplitube to get them to work again.
Note I tend to focus on the BAD things more than the GOOD.
In the extremely near future I'll try this on my wife's iPod Touch and buy the bass add-on so I can see how it really performs with bass guitar. I also plan on getting Peterson's iStrobotuner for use with setting up intonation and will use the iRig with that.
I'm hopeful this is just V1 of the Amplitube app and it'll improve in the future.